In recent years, LGBT rights and candidacies have expanded in Latin America. Some argue such progress may provoke a conservative reaction. Do voters punish gay candidates? To answer this, we conducted survey experiments in Argentina, Chile, and Mexico. We find no punishment in the general electorate; voters in Argentina and Chile reward gay candidates, while Mexican voters are indifferent. We then focus on right-wing voters, employing a typology that distinguishes between the moderate mainstream right and the reactionary far right. In Argentina and Mexico, right-wing voters do not penalize gay candidates. In Chile, however, voters aligned with the far-right Republican Party do. These findings suggest tolerance is stronger where mainstream right-wing forces prevail but weaker where far-right actors dominate. Finally, we find little variation in reactions to gay candidates by age but more negative reactions among men, evangelicals, the less educated, and those without personal contact with LGB individuals.